Posted in Book reviews, Revell Reads

Revell Book Review: “The Prophetess” by Jill Eileen Smith

“The Prophetess” by Jill Eileen Smith

Book 2 in the Daughters of the Promise Land Series (each can be read alone)

Review copy source: Revell

My rating: 2 out of 5 Stars


About the book:

Outspoken and fearless, Deborah has faith in God but struggles to see the potential her own life holds. As an Israelite woman, she’ll marry, have a family, and seek to teach her children about Adonai–and those tasks seem to be more than enough to occupy her time. But God has another plan for her. Israel has been under the near constant terror of Canaan’s armies for twenty years, and now God has called Deborah to deliver her people from this oppression. Will her family understand? Will her people even believe God’s calling on her life? And can the menace of Canaan be stopped?


My thoughts:

A story about Deborah, the judge, in the Bible sounded intriguing – I’ve never read a fiction adaption of that account before, so I was interested.
Unfortunately, I couldn’t really ‘click’ with the book, and didn’t like the portrayal of Deborah. All throughout this book, there were the “strong females” who were shown as better than the men – they were all headstrong, and disobedient, and it was portrayed as if it was a good thing. It disappointed me greatly.
I know everyone’s perception of Biblical accounts are different, but my personal thoughts are that if God chose Deborah for a judge, it was because He saw Himself in her – yes, she would’ve been human like the rest of us, but she would’ve had a heart after God, and would have been obedient to her husband as that is one of the traits God has desired in us.
There were several parts that had me rather appalled…
 “She fought the urge to awaken Lappidoth and complain profusely to him. Complaining did no good….but she could complain in her prayers,” – she complained to her husband constantly, and was very discontent in all things. And though I know we do it, God instructs us not to complain – He doesn’t encourage it. Yes, we can bring all things to Him in prayer, but He does desire for us to make an effort to “give thanks in all things”. Now, I’m not saying I’ve never complained (I sadly do, too), but the way it was shown in the book…it was more like nagging. And Biblical book characters should be encouraging and uplifting, not frustrating.
“If God were a Canaanite goddess, Deborah would have her answer. Anat the warrior goddess stood behind Sisera’s success. Asherah stood behind Canaan’s fertility. Baal stood behind Canaan’s king.” – This did not sit well with me at all. She was comparing God to the fake goddesses, and making it sound like God was inadequate and not as strong as those goddess’.
“You push too much, Jael.” “It’s a wife’s job to do so, my lord.” – No. This saddened me. The overall theme of this book screamed of headstrong women and their disregard for their heads. Every one of them. We should not encourage this in books.
As the verse says “Train up a child in the way he should go, and he will not soon depart from it” – that verse applies to all of us. In our endeavor to write Christian fiction, it should be our goal to help train others up in the way of God – in every way. Not giving the opposite message.
Therefore I cannot recommend this book. :(
There were also a few historical inaccuracies – one of the things I’ve seen many times in different Biblical fiction is “she forgot her headscarf” – a Hebrew young maiden would certainly not have forgotten this. It was a sign of her purity, her modesty, her respect.
Also, in this book, Deborah quoted a piece of scripture that David wrote in Psalms, and she wouldn’t have had that in her time.
But really, my main concern and dislike for this book was the head-strong-ness and disrespect. It grieved me a great deal.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publishers in exchange for my honest review, which I have given.*


I am a peculiar treasure who is passionately in love with my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. I love writing, reading, knife/tomahawk-throwing, and letter-writing, among other things. :)

9 thoughts on “Revell Book Review: “The Prophetess” by Jill Eileen Smith

  1. Books like this one, as it sounds Biblically inaccurate, are the reason I don’t read Biblical fiction. I would spend so much attention looking for things in it that aren’t correct according to the Bible, I wouldn’t be able to enjoy the story. That said, I don’t think about Biblical fiction is wrong, but I could never write it. I just wouldn’t feel write changing or adding to God’s holy Word. :)

    Thanks for the review, Raechel! You can make any review sound nice – even if you didn’t enjoy the book. ^_^

    1. Yes, I know exactly what you mean. And it is hard not to do that – almost impossible, really! I don’t think I could ever write it, either. I was be so nervous to do something wrong!
      I like Biblical Fiction, but I’ve found few that I can really approve of. Tessa Afshar is my favourite Biblical-fiction writer; she writes with such care and grace. Stephanie Landsem is another one I love. But yeah, it’s definitely a hard genre!

      Oh thank you so much for saying that, Faith! That was so kind of you. :) And thank you for commenting!

      1. I just looked up Tessa Afshar (Goodreads is seriously the best thing ever XD) and her book “In the Field of Grace” sounds really good!! I adore the story of Ruth. :)

        1. GoodReads is amazing, I agree!! It makes keeping track of books so much easier. Before I joined, I literally wrote every book I read down in a notebook along with my review. ^.^ And yes, “In the Field of Grace” is a good one! I love all of her books…don’t know if I could pick a favourite! :)

      2. Haha, same here! I have a notebook from when I was 10-11 and it has all the books I read that summer written in it. ☺️ Goodreads is so much easier! And neater – I had terrible handwriting then. 😉

  2. Thanks so much for the honest review! It’s hard to know which Biblical fiction you can trust and which you can’t.
    I haven’t read the book, I struggle with the ultra-strong women too. There’s a strength that comes from God and there’s a strength that comes from pride and sin. It seems that few people know the difference. :/

    1. It is. And exactly – I of course approve of God-given strength, but so often they portray prideful/sinful strength.
      Thank you for commenting! :)

Leave a Reply to Faith Potts Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.